LimitLine

Learn · updated 2026-10-28

Control Limits vs Specification Limits

By Nicholas Williford, Lean Six Sigma Black Belt · About LimitLine

Control limits are calculated from your process data and show whether it is stable; specification limits are set by the customer or the drawing and show whether a part is acceptable.

They look alike on a chart, two lines above and below the data, and that is where the confusion starts. They answer different questions and you act on them differently.

Control limitsSpecification limits
Set byYour process data (calculated)The customer or the drawing (given)
QuestionIs the process stable? Did something change?Is this part acceptable?
Typical positionMean ± 3σ of the plotted statisticWherever the design needs them
When a point is outsideLook for a special cause; something changedThe part is nonconforming; contain it
Also calledVoice of the process (UCL, LCL)Voice of the customer (USL, LSL, tolerance)

Both on One Chart

LimitLine's built-in example: NIST's ten flow-rate readings plus five more, with spec limits 45 to 57. The control limits come out of the data: center 51.34, UCL 58.71, LCL 43.97.

USL 57.00LSL 45.00UCL 58.71LCL 43.97CL 51.34Point 1: 49.6Point 2: 47.6Point 3: 49.9Point 4: 51.3Point 5: 47.8Point 6: 51.2Point 7: 52.6Point 8: 52.4Point 9: 53.6Point 10: 52.1Point 11: 50.6Point 12: 49.9Point 13: 60 (Signal)Point 14: 51.1Point 15: 50.413579111315
Point 13 (60.0) is above the UCL and the USL: a special cause and a bad part at the same time. The other fourteen are inside both.

Notice the control limits are wider than the spec here (43.97 to 58.71 against 45 to 57). That is point 13's doing: one special cause inflates the moving ranges and so the limits. Find its cause, leave it out and recalculate, and the limits come in to 46.43 to 55.02, inside the spec, with Cpk 1.33. Had they stayed wider than the spec, a stable process would still make some parts out of spec: a capability problem, fixed by changing the process rather than by chasing points.

The Four Cases

Inside the specOutside the spec
In controlGood: keep it there, keep chartingStable but not capable: change the process (spread or centering)
Out of controlSomething changed: find it before it ships bad partsContain the parts and find the special cause

The Mistake to Avoid: Spec Limits on an X̄ Chart

An X̄ chart plots averages of subgroups. Averages vary less than single parts, so a subgroup average can sit comfortably inside the spec while individual parts in it are out. Compare spec limits with individual values (an I-MR chart, a histogram or the capability study), never with averages. For the same reason, don't tighten control limits to the spec "to be safe": the limits describe the process, they are not a target.

Open this example in LimitLineThe app draws both sets of limits and says which case you are in. Free, no sign-up.

Sources

  1. NIST/SEMATECH e-Handbook of Statistical Methods, §6.3.1 What are control charts?
  2. NIST/SEMATECH e-Handbook, §6.1.6 What is Process Capability?
  3. AIAG (2005), Statistical Process Control (SPC) Reference Manual, 2nd edition, Automotive Industry Action Group

The LimitLine Newsletter

About one email a month: new guides, tool updates and one practical SPC tip. Unsubscribe in one click.

We'll email you once to confirm before anything else is sent. Privacy